Commandarium
Home › Commanders › Reanimator
Commander themes · Reanimator

Best Reanimator Commanders in MTG

In a Reanimator deck, losing a creature doesn’t have to mean losing access to it. You fill your graveyard deliberately, then bring back the creature you need. Some commanders repeat that process over many turns. Others help you put a large threat into play before you could comfortably cast it.

Build your Commander deckSee the commanders

Choose how your graveyard becomes a resource

Our picks cover different ways to build the theme. They are editorial recommendations, not a popularity or win-rate ranking.

  • Beginner-friendly A clear plan with few decisions per turn
  • Budget-friendly The commander is inexpensive and the deck works without pricey staples
  • High power Among the strongest versions of the theme
Meren of Clan Nel Toth — Magic: The Gathering card

Meren of Clan Nel Toth — bring creatures back every end step

Color identity: Black, GreenComplexity: MediumHigh powerBudget-friendly

Meren earns experience counters when your other creatures die. At the beginning of your end step, she returns a creature to the battlefield if its mana value is within your experience count; otherwise it goes to your hand. Cheap creatures with useful abilities give her something productive to do early.

Strengths

  • Brings a creature back at every end step
  • Creature deaths raise its experience cap
  • Two colors and four mana

Watch out for

  • Slow start: until the counters arrive it returns creatures to your hand
  • Graveyard hate shuts it off

Best for: Players who want a grindy engine that recovers from board wipes.

Build with this commanderBuy on TCGplayer
Karador, Ghost Chieftain — Magic: The Gathering card

Karador, Ghost Chieftain — cast creatures from the graveyard

Color identity: White, Black, GreenComplexity: LowBeginner-friendlyBudget-friendly

Creatures in your graveyard reduce Karador’s generic casting cost. During each of your turns, he also lets you cast a creature spell from there. You still pay that spell’s costs. Karador suits a toolbox of useful creatures better than a plan that assumes every large threat will return for free.

Strengths

  • Costs less for every creature card in your graveyard
  • Casts a creature from your graveyard once each turn, like a second hand
  • A forgiving, value-first plan

Watch out for

  • You still pay mana costs, so it is not instant reanimation
  • Three colors and a slow first turns

Best for: Newcomers who like value more than combos.

Build with this commanderBuy on TCGplayer
Chainer, Nightmare Adept — Magic: The Gathering card

Chainer, Nightmare Adept — trade a card for another chance

Color identity: Black, RedComplexity: MediumBudget-friendly

Chainer lets you discard a card to gain permission to cast a creature spell from your graveyard that turn, once each turn. He also gives haste to relevant creatures that didn’t enter from your hand. That makes him appealing for aggressive graveyard decks, provided you leave mana to actually cast the creatures.

Strengths

  • Turns spare cards into creature casts from the graveyard
  • Reanimated creatures can attack right away
  • Two colors and four mana

Watch out for

  • Casting costs mana, so nothing is free
  • Discarding a card every turn costs you resources

Best for: Players who like discard synergies and an aggressive plan.

Build with this commanderBuy on TCGplayer
Sefris of the Hidden Ways — Magic: The Gathering card

Sefris of the Hidden Ways — reanimate through dungeons

Color identity: White, Blue, BlackComplexity: High

Sefris ventures when creature cards go to your graveyard, at most once each turn, and returns a creature when you complete a dungeon. Discard outlets and actions on opponents' turns help the engine. Choose Sefris if you enjoy sequencing several moving parts rather than resolving one large reanimation spell.

Strengths

  • Ventures into the dungeon whenever creatures reach the graveyard
  • Completing a dungeon returns a creature to the battlefield
  • Only three mana

Watch out for

  • Dungeons take several rooms, so the deck needs a steady supply of creatures in the graveyard
  • Dungeon rules add complexity

Best for: Players who enjoy unusual engines and like to plan ahead.

Build with this commanderBuy on TCGplayer
Muldrotha, the Gravetide — Magic: The Gathering card

Muldrotha, the Gravetide — rebuild more than your creatures

Color identity: Blue, Black, GreenComplexity: MediumBudget-friendly

Muldrotha lets you play a land and cast a permanent spell of each permanent type from your graveyard during each of your turns. Timing rules and costs still apply. This is broader graveyard value rather than pure Reanimator, and works best when your answers and resources come on permanents.

Strengths

  • Plays a land and each permanent type from the graveyard every turn
  • Rewards self-mill and long games
  • Hard to run out of cards

Watch out for

  • Six mana and three colors
  • Slow in the first turns

Best for: Value players who want the graveyard as a second hand.

Build with this commanderBuy on TCGplayer

Opens the commander in Commandarium. Tap Build a deck around it: the deck is built from your collection first, and the cards you are missing go on a shopping list. Free, with no account needed; the build follows the Reanimator decks EDHREC lists for that commander.

TCGplayer links are affiliate links: we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Reanimator commanders compared

All five at a glance. Complexity and budget are our judgement; see each commander above for the reasons.

CommanderColorsPlanComplexityBudget-friendlyBuild
Meren of Clan Nel TothBring creatures back every end stepMediumYesBuild
Karador, Ghost ChieftainCast creatures from the graveyardLowYesBuild
Chainer, Nightmare AdeptTrade a card for another chanceMediumYesBuild
Sefris of the Hidden WaysReanimate through dungeonsHigh—Build
Muldrotha, the GravetideRebuild more than your creaturesMediumYesBuild

Put useful creatures in the graveyard, not just large ones

A working deck needs ways to fill the graveyard, ways to use it and targets worth recovering. Stitcher's Supplier can help stock it; Victimize exchanges a sacrificed creature for two creature cards returned tapped. Both are black and fit all five commanders above. Don’t include so many expensive targets that you struggle to play before your engine starts.

Graveyard exile is the obvious pressure point. Keep some threats you can cast normally and answers to the cards shutting off your graveyard.

Key cards and synergies for Reanimator

Cards that show up in many Reanimator decks, by the job they do. Which ones fit depends on your commander’s colors.

Filling the graveyard

Reanimation only works once something worth bringing back is down there.

  • Entomb — Puts any card from your library into your graveyard for one mana.
  • Buried Alive — Puts up to three creature cards from your library into your graveyard.
  • Stitcher's Supplier — A one-mana creature that mills three cards when it enters or dies.
  • Faithless Looting — Draws two, discards two, and comes back from the graveyard.

Reanimation spells

Bring a creature back from any graveyard.

  • Animate Dead — Returns a creature from a graveyard for two mana.
  • Reanimate — A single black mana, at the price of life equal to the creature’s mana value.
  • Victimize — Returns two creature cards at once if you sacrifice a creature.
  • Living Death — Swaps the creatures on the battlefield with the ones in every graveyard.

Creatures worth bringing back

Targets that win the game or give back more than they cost.

  • Grave Titan — Deathtouch, and two Zombies when it enters and whenever it attacks.
  • Sun Titan — Returns a permanent with mana value 3 or less when it enters or attacks.
  • Craterhoof Behemoth — Gives your team haste, trample and +X/+X, where X is the number of your creatures.
  • Eternal Witness — Returns any card from your graveyard to your hand when it enters.

Best budget Reanimator commanders

A budget reanimator deck is realistic: the best recursion engines and many of the strongest targets are inexpensive, and the expensive tutors and fast reanimation spells are nice to have, not required.

Karador, Ghost Chieftain

Karador, Ghost Chieftain

A cost reducer that grows with your graveyard and needs no expensive reanimation spells.

Build this deck
Muldrotha, the Gravetide

Muldrotha, the Gravetide

Casting from the graveyard each turn is value on its own, with ordinary cards.

Build this deck
Meren of Clan Nel Toth

Meren of Clan Nel Toth

Two colors, and the end-step trigger works with cheap creatures.

Build this deck

Prices change daily, so this page names none. Commandarium shows today’s price for every card in a deck, and counts what you already own.

Reanimator Commander FAQ

Is returning a creature the same as casting it?

No. Putting a creature directly onto the battlefield doesn’t trigger abilities that require you to cast it. Karador and Chainer provide casting permissions instead.

How is Reanimator different from Blink?

Reanimator uses creature cards in the graveyard. Blink usually exiles a permanent from the battlefield and returns it, reusing its enters abilities.

What happens if my graveyard gets exiled?

You lose those resources. A backup plan, interaction and cards you can cast from hand help you continue rather than depend entirely on one graveyard.

Build around the creatures you want back

Import your collection into Commandarium and start with a commander whose graveyard plan suits your cards.

Build my Reanimator deck

Opens Commandarium. Tap New deck on the start screen to see the possible commanders in your collection.

Related reading

Zombies

An army that comes back from the graveyard faster than the table can remove it.

Art: Chris Rallis · Wilhelt, the Rotcleaver10 commanders compared →

Aristocrats

Sacrifice your own creatures and drain the table with every death.

Art: Magali Villeneuve · Teysa Karlov10 commanders compared →

Blink

Exile your own permanents and bring them back to reuse their enters abilities.

Art: Karla Ortiz · Brago, King Eternal5 commanders compared →

More ways to start

Choose a commander

The legendary creatures you already own, as a starting point.

The deck builder

How Commandarium builds a deck from your collection.

Deck ratios

How many lands, ramp, draw and removal.

All commander themes

Every archetype we have compared.